Case note · Fraud & asset recovery · Technology disputes
CLM v CLN [2022] SGHC 46: freezing stolen crypto held by persons unknown
- Case
- CLM v CLN and others [2022] SGHC 46
- Court
- General Division of the High Court of Singapore
- Judge
- Lee Seiu Kin J
- Decided
- 4 March 2022 (grounds of decision)
- Judgment
- Read on eLitigation
- The first reported Singapore decision granting a proprietary injunction and a worldwide freezing injunction against persons unknown over stolen cryptocurrency.
- Unidentified thieves can be sued if they're described precisely enough to tell who is in and who is out.
- There was a serious arguable case that crypto is property under the Ainsworth criteria. That was enough for interim relief, though the point wasn't finally decided.
- Exchanges that received traced funds were joined as defendants and ordered to disclose account information.
The facts
The plaintiff, a US national, said that on or around 8 January 2021 his 109.83 BTC and 1,497.54 ETH were stolen from him, a claim valued at about US$7.09 million. Blockchain tracing followed part of the stolen Bitcoin into accounts at two exchanges, one incorporated in the Cayman Islands and one in the Seychelles, both with operations in Singapore. The thieves themselves could not be identified.
He sued the unknown thieves as the first defendants and joined the two exchanges, then applied without notice for urgent relief to stop the assets disappearing. That application was heard on 8 June 2021.
The issues
- Can proceedings, and injunctions, be brought against persons unknown?
- Is cryptocurrency property that can support a proprietary injunction?
- Were the requirements for a worldwide freezing injunction met?
- Can the court order exchanges to disclose information about the receiving accounts?
The decision
1. Persons unknown can be sued, if properly described
Drawing on English authority (including Bloomsbury and CMOC v Persons Unknown) and the Rules of Court then in force, the court accepted that it had jurisdiction to grant relief against unidentified defendants. The test is whether the description is sufficiently certain to identify who falls within it and who does not.
The description used was, in substance, any person or entity who carried out, participated in or assisted in the theft on or around 8 January 2021. It expressly excluded businesses providing cryptocurrency hosting or trading facilities in the ordinary course. That carve-out mattered: it kept innocent exchanges and custodians out of the injunction.
2. Crypto as property: a serious arguable case
Applying the four National Provincial Bank v Ainsworth criteria (definable, identifiable by third parties, capable of assumption by third parties, and having some permanence or stability), and following the New Zealand decision in Ruscoe v Cryptopia, the court found each criterion met. It therefore held there was a serious arguable case that the stolen BTC and ETH were property, and granted the proprietary injunction.
The court was careful to go no further. Interlocutory applications don't resolve complex questions of law, and earlier appellate decisions had left the precise nature of crypto property open.
3. Worldwide freezing injunction
The court also granted a worldwide freezing injunction against the unknown thieves up to US$7,089,894.68. On risk of dissipation, it required solid evidence, not bare assertion, and found it in the dishonest nature of the theft, wallets apparently set up to frustrate tracing, how easily crypto can be moved and hidden, and the absence of assets in Singapore.
4. Disclosure orders against the exchanges
The exchanges were ordered to disclose information about the accounts that had received the traced Bitcoin. The court relied on its power under section 4(10) of the Civil Law Act to grant ancillary orders in support of injunctions. A separate Bankers Trust order was unnecessary because the exchanges were already parties. In a later application, the court allowed further defendants to be joined, permitted service out of Singapore, and allowed substituted service by email.
Why it matters
- Speed wins. On-chain assets move in minutes. Get tracing evidence and draft papers ready early, so an application without notice can be made before funds are dispersed or cashed out.
- Draft the "persons unknown" description carefully. Tie it to the specific incident and date, and carve out exchanges and custodians acting in the ordinary course.
- Join the exchanges. Making the receiving exchanges defendants gives a direct route to disclosure of who is behind the accounts.
- Build the dissipation evidence. Courts expect specific evidence. The way the funds were moved after the theft is often the best evidence.
- Plan for service. Email service and service out of Singapore are available, but need to be applied for.
- For exchanges: expect disclosure and freezing orders, and make sure your terms and processes let you comply quickly while protecting other customers.
CLM v CLN is now the starting point for crypto asset recovery in Singapore. Later decisions, including ByBit Fintech v Ho Kai Xin [2023] SGHC 199, have taken the property analysis further. I'll cover these in separate case notes. For a token-level alternative to court action, see the burn and reissue remedy.
Frequently asked questions
Can you sue persons unknown in Singapore?
Is cryptocurrency property in Singapore?
Can a crypto exchange be ordered to reveal who holds an account?
Lost assets to a hack, scam or fraud? Read the first 72 hours, or get in touch.
This case note is general information and is not legal advice. It summarises a published judgment; read the full grounds of decision for the court's reasoning.
