Commentary · Technology disputes · Fraud & asset recovery
“You clicked I accept”: can crypto exchanges contract out of duties to their users?
- Exchange terms usually say the user is solely responsible for every instruction and the platform accepts no liability. That matters most when a genuine user is defrauded through contra trading.
- Neither Singapore, English nor Seychelles law lets a platform draft away all of its duties. Exclusions of negligence face a reasonableness test under UCTA, and Seychelles consumer law strikes out unfair terms.
- The best user-side argument: the terms allocate trading risk, not the risk that the exchange's own surveillance and controls fail in the face of obvious abuse.
Anyone who has opened an account with a bank or a centralised exchange has clicked through pages of small print. Buried in it is usually a blunt message: you are solely responsible for every instruction and transaction, and the platform accepts no liability for your losses.
That allocation of risk becomes critical when a genuine user is defrauded. A pattern I see more and more is engineered contra trading: the victim's account is compromised, a web of related accounts on the same exchange trades against it on heavily skewed terms, and value is extracted internally before being moved out. We have had meaningful success recovering assets for a victim of contra trading, so the picture is not as bleak as it first looks.
The starting point: the terms of use
On their face, the terms look fatal: the user "authorised" the trades and withdrawals, the exchange simply followed instructions, and losses fall on the user. But the real question isn't whether any duties survive the drafting. It is which duties survive, and how to frame them.
The Quincecare analogy
In traditional finance, banks owe a Quincecare duty: an implied contractual and concurrent tortious duty to use reasonable skill and care in executing instructions, and to refrain from executing them when put on notice of possible fraud. The duty can be limited or excluded by contract, but only subject to statutory and common law controls. Exchange terms often try to exclude any duty to review or question users' instructions, whether framed as a Quincecare-style duty or an obligation to restrict fresh transactions once on notice of a compromise.
How the law controls exclusion clauses
Singapore
The Unfair Contract Terms Act regulates exclusions of negligence and other breaches of duty, particularly on a business's written standard terms. Such clauses must be reasonable, judged by factors such as bargaining power, how far the term was brought to the user's attention, and whether the user had any real choice. UCTA also scrutinises terms that, in substance, let a business perform materially differently from what was reasonably expected, or not perform at all.
England
The Unfair Contract Terms Act 1977 applies a similar reasonableness test. Banking cases accept in principle that a Quincecare-type duty can be curtailed by clear language, but only if the clause, properly construed, does so and passes the statutory test. The courts distinguish clauses that define the primary obligation from true exclusions of liability for performing it negligently.
Seychelles
Many offshore exchanges are incorporated in the Seychelles, which has no direct UCTA equivalent. But the Consumer Protection Act 2010 and the Financial Consumer Protection Act 2022 make unfair terms unenforceable where they create a significant imbalance to the consumer's detriment or are contrary to good faith. Broad "no duty" clauses in standard exchange terms can still be attacked.
Building a claim around contra trading
- Limit what the terms can do. Challenge the reasonableness of any exclusion of negligence, and argue that the clause, properly construed, allocates trading risk but not the risk of the exchange's own controls failing in the face of obvious abuse.
- Anchor duties in the platform's role and rules. An exchange is not a bulletin board. It runs a closed ecosystem, holds customer assets, sets the matching and liquidation logic, and publishes fraud and market integrity policies. Those documents, and the regulatory framework, set a baseline of reasonable care that can't be signed away entirely.
- Make the red flags unavoidable. Use logs, trading data and expert analysis to show the pattern (counterparties, pricing, speed, subsequent withdrawals) was so stark that any reasonable exchange applying its own rules would have frozen or escalated it.
The regulatory backdrop
Licensed digital payment token service providers in Singapore are expected to have robust risk management, surveillance and user protection measures, including AML/CFT monitoring and suspicious transaction reporting. Those public law expectations feed into the private law analysis. It is hard for a platform to argue it can contract out of acting on glaring red flags when its licence depends on having systems designed to detect them.
Terms of use remain a major hurdle, and courts are wary of rewriting risk allocation. But where fraudsters weaponise an exchange's own architecture through orchestrated contra trading, the law still asks whether the platform did enough, however many times the user clicked "I agree".
Frequently asked questions
Can a crypto exchange exclude all liability for fraud on my account?
What is contra trading?
General information only, not legal advice, and not a substitute for advice on any specific matter.
